[Nagant1899]

What would you suggest for off the shelf arrows? Bloodsport Hunter, Bloodsport Witness or Black Eagle Executioners.

 

[SavedWretch]

I have both the Witness' and Executioners. I honestly don't think there's much if any difference in how they shoot. I think I slightly prefer the BEE's but that could be because I paid $49 for six and I got the Witness' on closeout for $17 per six.
I think the Hunters are the same arrows as the Witness' only with a lighter insert.

 

[robertyb]

I agree that on factory fletched the BS and BEEs shoot about the same. I bought the BS Hunters (300 grain bare) on Amazon at $29.99 per 6. The Witness go 325 grains bare and are about $5 more per 6.