Crossbow Nation banner

Do deer see lighted reticle scopes? Opinion?

723 views 39 replies 31 participants last post by  Blacktail  
#1 ·
I shot my best buck ever Saturday evening. A big 8 point.

It was starting to get kind of dark and I had just turned on my lighted reticle just in case.

Soon there after he came in and stopped behind some small trees. Right around 22 yards. I'm on the ground behind a make shift blind made of some camouflage fabric and natural vegetation. Wind in my favor. It took him 9 minutes to basically move about 3 yards. Which seemed like forever with me frozen shouldering the bow. Luckily I have a rest. Just before he takes his final step offering me a clear shot at the vitals. He turns his head and stares right at me. There's not much of me to be seen and I was completely still other than my pounding heart! It just seemed like he saw that lit reticle and was trying to figure out what it was. He turned his head back and took that last step and I let it fly.

It's a Vortex crossfire II scope. I had it on the dimmest red setting. I've killed a number of deer with the reticle on and have never seen one react like this. Was it just my paranoia or coincidence. What say you?
Image
 
#7 ·
Can they? Maybe. Will it spook them? Maybe but I doubt it. I live well out in the country, 5 miles from a town of <400, 15 miles to the next town of 1200 and there are still lights visible everywhere. If every light spooked deer they would die of fright at sunset. I also can't believe they are intelligent enough to know where every single permanent light is located and recognize a new one. Or perhaps, thankfully, I am surrounded by deer as dumb as me.
 
#36 · (Edited)
Spot on! ... Could have been scent left from when the wind had swirled shortly before he showed up, could have been anything for him to lock up. If you've ever blown leaves in the yard there's one thing you quickly realize is the wind rarely if ever is steady in one direction. There are always swirls and reverses. They maybe short, but they do happen. I've seen deer take 30 minutes to move 30 yards. Standing, staring, whiffing the air.
Image
 
#12 ·
Seems like I remember reading about it somewhere before and that may have been it. I know I've read on here before about some not wanting to use glow in the dark vanes in low light conditions.

I made a video years ago shooting a slower 290fps bow with luminoks. Imo a deer could probably see it coming. I'll see if I can find and post it.

The more I think about this it was probably just my paranoia. If he did see it It didn't spook him as he eventually turned his head back forward and took that final fatal step.

Here's that video

 
#14 ·
I think I have seen this with a lighted reticle or at least it sure seemed like she noticed it. A doe seem to notice something was off with the reticle when I had it on.

My Dad told me years ago he has a keller pendulum bow sight on his compnd bow and the deer looked up and saw the light on that he said. Not quite the same as the lighted scope reticle but just saying. Who knows, but they sure do seem to have the ability to sense something is off.
 
#17 ·
I don’t know either but I do know deer don’t miss much. I have seen them go on full alert over some deadfall I moved from in front of my ground blind. They knew something was up!!
Bill
 
#18 ·
I believe they can. Especially if you're ground level in a very dark blind. I've had it happen a few times where at last light, in a ground blind they were staring right at me. I would be covered in dark clothing/mask but somehow they were staring into the blind and being spooky about it. Oddly enough, I was also using a vortex crossfire II.
 
#19 ·
At the time I took the shot I didn't need the reticle lit. It was about 7 minutes after sunset and I wasn't in a covered dark blind. After he seemed to notice. I was thinking I should have left it off. Yet I didn't want to possibly get busted turning it on if it had got darker. If he did see it ,it didn't seem to spook him but maybe just made him curious. I'm just glad it all worked out. This was a couple of hours earlier.
Image
 
#21 ·
Great Buck!!! Congrats!!!! I believe that some deer truly do have a "sixth sense " , but I know for a fact that they notice the smallest change in their core areas....a hunters outline 20' up in a tree...a shadow/blob that wasn't there the last time they walked through that spot....the slight odor change....we're talking the deers house/bedroom

Humans have the same ability....when you keep your house organized a certain way....you might notice a item out of place, item moved, or a subtle difference when you come back home...it would catch your eye just like that Buck noticed something was wrong IMO.
 
#23 ·
Onlyaspike said it best, you are in HIS bedroom, living room or whatever you want to call it. Deer notice things! It's how they survive in a world full of predators. I've seen deer walk by tree stands a hundred times and never look up, you put a hunter in that stand, and they'll stop and stare at it like a fat gal looking at a cake!
They are wired that way, it's something different in their home.

As for lights emitting from a lit reticle, if you can see it, so can they. However, they would have to be looking directly at you back up the scope tube to your face. So, it's not really a concern to me. I have never used a lit reticle to kill a deer. My scopes have that feature, I just don't use it.

What the deer notice most is the different "blob" on that stand, or even a darker spot in that bush that's always been there.
I remember going to a sniper school many years ago and the main thing they harped on the most in "field craft" was the ability to match your immediate surroundings. One little thing out of the ordinary would get you spotted and "killed".
The instructors would be up on towers looking for you with binos. You had a starting point, about 1/4 mile away and would have to "travel undetected" to within 100 yards of your target, all the time being looked for.
Sure makes you think twice about your 'camo".

Just think of that "target buck" as your instructor looking for you!
 
#27 ·
Onlyaspike said it best, you are in HIS bedroom, living room or whatever you want to call it. Deer notice things! It's how they survive in a world full of predators. I've seen deer walk by tree stands a hundred times and never look up, you put a hunter in that stand, and they'll stop and stare at it like a fat gal looking at a cake!
They are wired that way, it's something different in their home.

As for lights emitting from a lit reticle, if you can see it, so can they. However, they would have to be looking directly at you back up the scope tube to your face. So, it's not really a concern to me. I have never used a lit reticle to kill a deer. My scopes have that feature, I just don't use it.

What the deer notice most is the different "blob" on that stand, or even a darker spot in that bush that's always been there.
I remember going to a sniper school many years ago and the main thing they harped on the most in "field craft" was the ability to match your immediate surroundings. One little thing out of the ordinary would get you spotted and "killed".
The instructors would be up on towers looking for you with binos. You had a starting point, about 1/4 mile away and would have to "travel undetected" to within 100 yards of your target, all the time being looked for.
Sure makes you think twice about your 'camo".

Just think of that "target buck" as your instructor looking for you!
Im very camo conscious. Earlier on this hunt I had a Doe see me as I arrived and was settling in my spot. She wasn't sure what I was and came in for a closer look. After a few minutes of staring and uneasyness she wandered off. About an hour and half later she snuck in undetected and caught me moving my head. She did the whole stomp stare thing trying to get me to move again at 20 yards. She finally relaxed and meandered off again. This was my first hunt of the season. For some reason my little turkey seat seamed to be sitting higher than normal. Exposing my shoulders and head more than normal maybe 2 inches. Made me feel like I was sticking out like a sore thumb! I tried to dig out underneath the legs with my fingers and a stick but the ground was just too hard so I had to go with it. The buck wasn't alarmed like she was and I hadn't moved at all. I just thought it possibly may have been the scope. Then again like you and others have said. I was something new to his world.

Here's my camo setup.
Image


About all they can see of me is the top of my head behind the limbs and scope. And maybe my beady little eyes:geek:
 
#26 ·
IMO your buck is a mature buck and my experience is if a mature buck sees something that puts it on alert in the least he will not take another step into the open but will back out and disappear fast. They don't get to 4 years or older by being stupid until the rut is in. I think his 6th sense made him stare in your direction and he decided there was nothing to worry about so he took that final step. Congrats on a very nice 8 point.
 
#28 ·
Not sure on whether or not he saw the lit crosshairs, I would think not unless the crosshairs were aiming on an exact plane with his eyes and any slightest deviation would’ve made the crosshair disappear, prob more of he just knew something was a little iffy and couldn’t figure it out…helluva 8-pointer!
 
#29 ·
I think your probably right like others have said too.

Mainly because he turned his head back and slowly took that last step.

It did scare the hell out of me though, Thinking he may bolt and be gone.